November 5, 2024
ShareKelley Kronenberg Secures Summary Judgment Victory in $40K Vehicle Theft Case
Kelley Kronenberg Attorney Jasmine Hall, alongside Partner/Business Unit Leader Elizabeth Hernandez, secured a significant victory in a negligence case through a successful Motion for Summary Judgment. The ruling, delivered by Judge Dawn Hudson in Jacksonville, Florida, dismissed all claims against their client, Subaru of Jacksonville.
The case stemmed from allegations of vehicle theft at the Subaru dealership. The plaintiff claimed that after leaving his vehicle for maintenance in May 2022, he discovered the alleged theft seven months later upon receiving a toll invoice. The plaintiff sought damages of $40,233.87, citing the vehicle’s value and impact on his credit score.
Through meticulous investigation and compelling legal arguments, our defense team thoroughly discredited the plaintiff’s allegations. Jasmine and Elizabeth presented a robust defense demonstrating that Subaru of Jacksonville maintained proper security protocols and safeguards for all customer vehicles in their care. The defense established that not only did the plaintiff fail to provide any evidence of negligence or wrongdoing by the dealership, but there was substantial evidence suggesting the vehicle could have been accessed by the plaintiff himself or someone with authorized access to a second set of keys.
Judge Hudson’s decisive ruling confirmed what the defense had maintained throughout the proceedings: the plaintiff failed to establish both the existence of a duty of care and any breach thereof—essential elements in proving negligence. The complete dismissal of all claims through summary judgment validates Subaru of Jacksonville’s commitment to customer service and security.
This victory reinforces Kelley Kronenberg’s expertise in defending reputable businesses against unsubstantiated claims and highlights Subaru of Jacksonville’s continued dedication to maintaining the highest standards of customer vehicle care and protection.
To learn more about how Kelley Kronenberg’s General Liability Division successfully defends automotive industry clients through strategic motions and comprehensive analysis of duty-of-care standards in negligence claims, click here.
Stay up to date on the latest developments in general liability and third-party insurance. Click here to read the latest issue of our newsletter, “In the Know: General Liability Edition.”