Matthew S. Garnett

Partner

Matthew S. Garnett Attorney Profile | Kelley Kronenberg

Overview

Matthew Garnett is a Partner and Business Unit Leader at Kelley Kronenberg. He focuses his practice on general liability and third-party insurance defense, including representation of both carriers and insureds for all commercial and professional lines.  

Matthew has nearly two decades of legal experience which extends across diverse practice areas, including significant experience in the professional liability arena (e.g., defense of attorneys, physicians, architects and engineers, real estate professionals, directors and officers, etc.). In addition, Matthew has performed substantial work defending claims involving premises liability, negligent security, commercial trucking accidents, construction defect, products liability and first-party property insurance. Finally, Matthew has dedicated a meaningful portion of his career to the representation of private clients facing employment law matters, franchisor/franchisee disputes, hospitality industry regulatory and business disputes, long-term care industry transactional and regulatory matters, and intellectual property disputes. 

Throughout his career, Matthew’s work has gravitated towards the most challenging and high stakes litigation within his practice areas, and this has resulted in significant experience defending claims against the most well-resourced and aggressive adversaries. His approach to litigation focuses on candidly weighing the ‘cost of results’ at all stages with clients and insurance professionals. 

Before joining Kelley Kronenberg, Matthew was managing partner for a distinguished practice group in Miami, Florida. In this role, in addition to formulating the strategic approach for all litigation within the department, he also built an impressive winning record as a first-chair trial attorney. 

Matthew earned his Juris Doctorate in 2006 from Vanderbilt University Law School, where he served as the Executive Editor for the Vanderbilt Journal of Entertainment and Technology Law, as well as a member of the Law Review/Law Journal Write-On Competition Audit Committee. 

  • Florida 
  • United States District Court, Middle District of Florida 
  • United States District Court, Southern District of Florida 
  • Vanderbilt University Law School, J.D., 2006 
  • University of Rochester, B.A., 2000 
  • American Architectural Metals & Glass – Client sued by Golden Beach GC for design defects in 20M residential property. Complex coverage issues and personal counsel dealings. Case resolved for 1/10 of claimed damages.
  • Acquisition Consultants – Broker sued for professional negligence in Orange County failing to identify suitable office space for client due to alleged conflict of interest. Confidential settlement. Tokio Marine.
  • Haggard Law Firm v. Gunther Legal – 1.137M in funds sent by ACH diverted to fraudulent actors. Confidential settlement. CNA Specialty Insurance.
  • Woodward v. Allen – Pre-suit matter resolved for $2000.00 in connection with allegation that 4-Point Inspector missed obvious electrical issues in home that led to fire shortly after purchase. Carrier made business decision.
  • Planet Hollywood Litigation – Allegations against company that hackers infiltrated POS software and were able to lift credit card numbers for months prior to discovery. Multi-defendant litigation. We represented a IT security consultant and resolved claim on favorable terms.
  • Sebastian Jaramillo, P.A. Legal Malpractice Claim – Alleged negligence in serving as counsel for land development deal. Case settled without payment from carrier two weeks after mediation.
  • Zeiger Crane – Personal Injuries to employee of subcontractor due to alleged negligence of client. Complicated WC issues and case resolved for 50k to prevent appeal of SJ motion that was likely to be successful.
  • FDIC as Receiver for Colonial Bank v. Pearl – Federal suit where FDIC alleged that Pearl negligently prepared a property appraisal for a Bradenton condominium that led to a subsequent loss when mortgagor stopped making payment. Our work led to a global settlement of all nationwide claims against Navigators and put an end to the cottage industry that the FDIC developed after the Colonial Bank fiasco.


Practice Areas




Accolades, Associations & News